Whats the harm with alternative medicine if we are sure it doesn't work?
When normal means of medicine fails us, some will turn to alternative
medicine for treatment. However,
when conventional medicine for extremely treatable conditions is subsided
for alternative means of medication and therapy, the result can essentially be
a fatality. Ultimately, the decision comes down to the patient, but not in all
cases. A website called whattheharm.net shows just a small portion of a list of
people who have died from using medicine outside the reins of evidence based
science. Now, this is not the say at all, in any way that the medicine itself
had killed them, but rather the lack of actual medication to treat these
conditions. Probably the most recent prolific case is the case with Steve Jobs,
who sought out alternative medicine to cure him of pancreatic cancer and sought
out spiritualists to heal him, as opposed to doctors.
Whats the harm with Terminal Cancer?
Most stories that involve alternative medicine are orientated
around cancer. So, if the patient is terminal, what is the harm in them seeking
alternative care? One word; hope.
Many of these naturopaths, who don’t have degrees in medicine and have no idea
what they are doing, claim that they can cure
the cancer. Granted, there is the odd case where the cancer will just go away
on its own. The antibodies will destroy the cancer cells, and the patient will
become healthy and normal again. This, by no means, is down to ‘alternative
medicine’. This is genuinely just a luck of the draw. Then there are those that
don’t survive, but have sought alternative treatment. In 1999, Ed Gochenour had
his brain tumour treated using alternative medicine. The doctor was prosecuted
by the FDA, with Ed testifying in court that the treatment worked and he was
cured of his cancer. The patient died nearly two years later, from the original
brain tumour. Again, in 2007 Mary Nedlouf had previously undergone treatment
for breast cancer in the summer of 2006. In 2007, the cancer had reoccurred and
she was told it was inoperable. After seeking alternative medicine, she was
charged $3,000 (around £2000) a week for autosanguis and bioresonance therapy
for her treatment from Dr Nakouzi. He told her, he would cure her cancer with
these techniques and saying he would get to the ‘root of the cancer’ and
prescribed a daily regimen of 40 pill supplements. Not too shockingly, but
unfortunately, Mary died after two weeks of ‘treatment’. Her husband was quoted
saying:
"[Nakouzi] robbed
me of precious time to console her, to come to closure, to prepare for her
departure."
That is pretty much the reality of alternative medicine. He gave hope to her and to
her husband by using therapy which has absolutely no scientific merit at all.
11 Year Old Dies Through Alternative Treatment
In January of this year, an 11 year old girl named Makalya Sault from Ontario, Canada
died from an acute case of lymphoblastic leukemia. This is a cancer of the
white blood cells, which induces an overproduction of immature white blood
cells (lymphoblasts). With chemotherapy, the prognosis is
usually good, giving at least 5 years without re-occurrence. Makaylas parents
were pastors, their faith being Christianity. On the basis of religious grounds,
they had this 11 year old girl removed from chemotherapy treatment and put her
in a health institution for alternative therapy. Here, she received ‘cold laser
therapy’ and vitamin C injections. These, have absolutely no effect on
leukemia. After she had died the family blamed the hospital in Canada for the
chemotherapy she received, claiming it caused irrevocable damage to her heart. –
Also, in that article, it indicates that this girl CHOSE to give up chemo. She
really didn’t have a choice in this; this was her parent’s decision. Many of the news articles state this girl 'refused conventional treatment', but that is really hard to believe in an 11 year old girl would make that authoritative decision. It's ridiculous enough that freedom of religion allowed the means for this tragic death, let alone the decision of her parents were allowed to take effect. Actual real
doctors, not alternative therapists, stated she died after suffering a stroke
due to the relapse of leukemia.
Who is to blame?
In the case above, who do we blame? The parents blame the
chemo, the doctors blame the cancer, the media blames the parents. Was it the
parents fault for being so succumbed to the thought and promise of a cure?
Well, that arguable. Should the government be blamed because they didn’t try to
circumvent this occurrence, instead, they allowed it to happen? But, I believe,
blame should really be placed on the practitioners that propagate these
evidently false claims of cures for cancer.
“People have been living on earth for about 250,000 years. For the
past 5,000 healers have been trying to heal the sick. For all but the past 200,
they haven’t been very good at it.”
Never has a truer statement been said. It’s is often
discussed that alternative medicine is seen as a cult, drawing people in with
good sales pitches and keeping them there. These people are phenomenally under educated
in the realm of science. You have to be careful with the people who claim they
know the ‘source’ of cancer and the ‘cures’ for cancer. Cancer is ridiculously
complex and as I have discussed in another blog post (Is cannabis the cure for cancer?), does not have one unified treatment. There are several different
cancers and several different treatments out there for some types of these cancers, but, there is no one universal, cure
all, cancer treatment. It is alternative therapists who see a weakness in these people
and take full advantage of it, and really it is despicable. Another case is
discussed here, where a woman named Kim Tinkham was conned into using
alternative medicine for her breast cancer. Dr. Young was quoted saying ‘there
is no such thing as cancer’ and blamed her when the treatment didn’t work
because she didn’t ‘truly believe’.
It really does work, I’ve read this story where…
No, it doesn’t work. As discussed earlier, there can be just
a random occurrence that your body fights off the cancer with no treatment,
which is often described as a ‘miracle’. These stories are through the words of
a patient, there is no scientific proof or evidence behind these cases about
the efficacy of alternative treatment. They provide a myriad of scientific
inaccuracy and most often fail to point out the fact that alternative therapy
is being used alongside actual medical techniques such as radiotherapy. Thus,
the radiotherapy is helping the cancer recede, not the activated charcoal you
are putting in your organic, no fat, no milk, no coffee and no chemical latte.
Belle Gibson, a shamefully despicable woman, built her business
around her story of having healed herself of a brain tumour through the
controlling of her diet. She sold recipe books, claiming to have the cures for
cancer through eating the right ingredients. It has been discovered, now, that
she never had cancer at all. Even worse, in that interview, she appears to have
no remorse of fabricating these claims and profiting of scared people with life
threatening ailments.
Conclusion
Believers in alternative medicine eve infiltrate the NHS, just
a few months ago we had David Tredinnick, an advocate of astrological
medicine and homeopathy, running for a seat allowing him to integrate
alternative medicine into the NHS. A few months ago I heard of a friend going
to the doctors with severe mood swings due to hormone imbalance and told to
take some homeopathic treatment for that. You as a patient have the right to
deny medicine and ask questions regardless of the situation. If you feel the
medicine recommended isn’t correct, seek a second opinion. A feel a lot of
people turn to alternative medicine because they don’t trust doctors or ‘big
pharma’. But these people are trying to help, as much as you think they aren’t.
They are much more informed than alternative therapists and will tell you the
side effects of the treatment. Cases where people received coffee enemas for
common ailments have a serious risk of contracting septicaemia, which isn’t
exactly discussed as a side effect in alternative treatments.
The common thing to look out for and be careful off is an
alternative medicine quackers use of the ‘historical use of herbal/alternative
medicine’. This, in its basic form is an appeal to antiquity, which is a
logical fallacy. They are essentially claiming that this medicine works, because
it was used historically. This fact does not give any credence to evidence;
these treatments were probably no more effective than they are now. Beware of
buzzwords such as ‘oxidation’ and ‘cancer causing’, these are classic signs you
are onto alternative pathways (but not always). This can be demonstrated here.
To get to this website, I typed into google ‘cancer cured by cheese’, you can
probably type in anything and get a quack result. The top result was ‘cancer
cured by baking soda’, for the sake of my own mental capability; I am not going
to click on it (I’m sure that another post will cover it). If there was
evidence that alternative therapy works just as well as conventional medicine,
they would stand up as one united treatment. They are completely separate entities,
one based on myths and promises of cures, the other based on evidence and truth. Take your pick, but who’s to blame when you die from a lack due care
with one of these?